74 years ago
Willie Pep vs Sandy Saddler III
Date: 8th September 1950
Venue: Yankee Stadium, The Bronx, New York
Title: World Featherweight Title
Promoter: International Boxing Club
Willie Pep
(
152
-
2
-
1
)
Weight: 124¾ lbs
Sandy Saddler
(
115
-
7
-
2
)
Weight: 124¾ lbs
The Willie Pep vs. Sandy Saddler III bout, a pivotal moment in the annals of featherweight boxing, unfolded on September 8, 1950, at Yankee Stadium, The Bronx, New York. This was the third clash between Pep and Saddler, with the World Featherweight Championship at stake, marking Pep's fourth defence of his second reign as champion. The match drew a massive crowd of 38,781 spectators, setting new records for attendance and gross gate receipts at a featherweight bout, underscoring the intense fascination with this rivalry.
Despite Willie Pep's status as the reigning champion and his reputation as a nimble boxer, he stepped into the ring as the underdog, with odds of 8-5 favouring Sandy Saddler. This perception was largely due to Saddler's imposing physique, raw power, and aggressive fighting style, which were viewed as advantages over the elusive Pep.
The fight was a fierce battle, with both pugilists seizing their opportunities. Saddler's most memorable moment came in the third round when he sent Pep sprawling with a devastating left hook. Pep, however, quickly regained his composure and fought back valiantly, leveraging his superior footwork and speed to land a barrage of jabs and right crosses that left Saddler disoriented and with a rapidly swelling left eye.
However, the bout also took a rough turn. Saddler's tactics, which included wrestling and physical manhandling, appeared to focus on wearing Pep down by any means necessary. Pep, frustrated by Saddler's approach and his physical disadvantages, responded with his share of questionable tactics, including thumbing and stepping on Saddler's toes.
The match reached a turning point at the end of the seventh round when a severe dislocation of Pep's left shoulder forced him to retire on his stool before the start of the eighth round. The injury was significant enough that Dr. Vincent Niardello of the New York State Athletic Commission had to reset it on-site. Pep attributed the injury to Saddler's roughhousing rather than a specific punch.
This controversial ending to the fight left a mixed feeling among the boxing community and fans, with many disappointed by the tactics employed and the unsatisfactory conclusion. The referee, Ruby Goldstein, and the judges had Pep ahead on points at the time of the stoppage, reflecting his effective boxing despite the challenges posed by Saddler.
The fight's aftermath was filled with both fighters expressing dissatisfaction with each other's methods. Pep lamented Saddler's wrestling moves, which he felt were deliberate attempts to cause injury rather than legitimate boxing tactics. Saddler, on the other hand, dismissed claims that he had twisted Pep's arm, suggesting instead that a kidney punch might have caused the injury, and pointed out that Pep had used illegal tactics as well.
Their rivalry was intense enough to prompt discussions of a fourth fight, as their matches' competitive and financial appeal remained high. However, the series of fights between Pep and Saddler continued to be marred by fouls and contentious tactics, culminating in their fourth and final match. This match ended in a similar controversy and ultimately led to the suspension of their boxing licenses by the New York State Athletic Commission due to the unsportsmanlike conduct displayed.
The Willie Pep vs. Sandy Saddler trilogy remains one of the most talked-about rivalries in boxing history. It is noted for the skill displayed and the controversy surrounding their encounters.
Willie Pep vs Sandy Saddler 3 on YouTube
