From the archive · December 15, 2000
Dingaan Thobela vs Dave Hilton
WBC World Super Middleweight Title · Molson Centre, Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Record 40-7-2 · 166½ lb
Record 39-2-2 · 160½ lb

The fight
Dave Hilton took the WBC world super middleweight championship from Dingaan Thobela by a split decision over twelve rounds at the Molson Centre in Montreal on December 15, 2000. The Canadian’s victory brought a second world championship to the Hilton family, following his brother Matthew’s success at junior middleweight in 1987. It also produced an immediate dispute, with Thobela insisting that he had done enough to retain his title. Julie Lederman scored the contest 115-113 for Hilton and Barbara Perez returned 117-111 in his favour. Oren Shellenberger preferred Thobela by 115-113.
Thobela, aged 34, was making his first defence of the championship he had won by stopping Glenn Catley in the final round at Brakpan in September. Previously a WBA and WBO lightweight champion, the South African had reached this contest through a substantial rise in weight. Hilton, 37, was receiving his first world championship opportunity after a professional career stretching back to 1981. He had lost a decision to Stéphane Ouellet in September, having stopped the same opponent in their previous two meetings. Nevertheless, his established following ensured strong support from the Montreal crowd.
Hilton began by pressing the action, taking the initiative while Thobela worked his way into the contest. His trainer, Chuck Talhami, had identified an early body attack as the means of weakening the champion. Thobela’s stated intention was to use his jab and movement while refusing to surrender ground unnecessarily. The opening exchanges gave Hilton encouragement, although the judges differed even at this stage: all three awarded him the first round, but Lederman gave Thobela the second. Referee Elmo Adolph warned Hilton in the third, prompting boos from the home spectators.
Thobela established a stronger position through the middle rounds. All three judges awarded him the fourth and sixth, while Lederman and Shellenberger also scored the fifth for the champion. On Lederman’s card, Thobela won four successive rounds from the fourth through the seventh. Hilton’s close work complicated the South African’s efforts to maintain his attack, and Thobela subsequently complained that the challenger’s holding had prevented him from punching freely. The contest remained sufficiently competitive for differences over these passages to become decisive in the final reckoning.
Hilton recovered ground as the fight entered its later stages. Every judge gave him the eighth, but all three did not agree on another round until the eleventh. Lederman scored each of the final five rounds for Hilton, overturning the advantage she had given Thobela earlier. Perez also favoured Hilton throughout the last three. Shellenberger saw those closing exchanges differently, awarding Thobela the tenth and twelfth, with Hilton taking the eleventh. Thus the Canadian’s strong finish secured the championship on two cards without producing agreement among the officials about who had controlled the closing stages.
Thobela challenged the verdict afterwards. “I did enough to retain my title, but the judges saw the fight differently,” he said. Catley, watching from ringside with an interest in facing the winner, also believed the South African had prevailed: “I think Thobela had done enough to win.” Hilton, meanwhile, was carried in celebration by members of his party and dedicated his championship success to his ailing grandfather and the people of Quebec. After twelve closely disputed rounds, he held the title, while Thobela’s first defence had ended in a defeat he refused to accept as a fair reflection of the contest.
The House on this fight
I respect Hilton’s pressure, but that wide scorecard was too generous. Thobela had just stopped Catley and deserved credit for his work through the middle rounds. Hilton started well and finished strongly, but holding and home support aren’t substitutes for clean punching. For me, a close verdict was arguable. Giving Hilton nine rounds badly overstated his superiority in this contest.
