Joe Calzaghe vs Charles Brewer

At the Cardiff International Arena on 20 April 2002, Joe Calzaghe retained the WBO super-middleweight title with a unanimous decision over Charles Brewer after 12 rounds that were much harder than the final arithmetic suggested. The referee was Mark Nelson, and the judges scored it 117-112, 118-111 and 119-109, all for Calzaghe, in what was his tenth defence of the title he had won from Chris Eubank. Both men were listed at 167.75 pounds for the contest, though Brewer had reportedly come in heavy at an earlier stage of the weigh-in process. Before a crowd reported at about 5,000, Calzaghe remained unbeaten at 33-0, while Brewer, the former IBF champion from Philadelphia, gave him one of the sternest nights of his reign.

The pattern of the fight was established quickly enough. Calzaghe, boxing from the southpaw stance and fighting with the familiar high tempo that had already become his trademark, took command of the early rounds with speed, work-rate and variety. He was first with the jab, first with the left hand, and when Brewer tried to answer in kind, he often found Calzaghe already halfway through another combination. Brewer was not easy to discourage, and he did not behave like a visitor who had come for a careful defeat; in the first third of the contest, he was second to the punch and to the initiative. The scorecards reflect that clearly: all three judges gave Calzaghe the first five rounds, with only the sixth round producing any disagreement, with one judge calling it even and another giving it to Brewer.

Brewer’s merit lay in the fact that he absorbed the early rush without losing either his shape or his appetite for the fight. He was wobbled, according to contemporary ringside reporting, but he did not wilt, and from the middle rounds onward, he began to make Calzaghe work in a rather different way. He forced exchanges more often, stayed in front of the champion longer, and found openings with the left hand as Calzaghe’s pace became harder to sustain. The seventh was especially notable. Brewer landed a hurtful left that made Calzaghe wince, and two of the three judges gave the round to the challenger. It was the point in the fight when the contest ceased to look like a routine title defence and became a proper argument between an unbeaten champion and a hard, seasoned former titleholder who was not especially interested in applause for effort.

Calzaghe’s better work, though, continued to come in longer spells and cleaner bursts. Even when Brewer dragged him into a more physical fight, Calzaghe still had the quicker hands and the wider menu of punches. Brewer had success when he could slow the exchanges and make the Welshman stand his ground, but Calzaghe was usually able to reclaim the initiative before the round was beyond rescue. The official cards tell their own story in the later stages. Two judges gave Brewer the eleventh, one judge gave him the tenth, but Calzaghe was back in front on all three cards in the twelfth, closing the bout in the same spirit with which he had begun it. Contemporary reports described the last round as fierce, and that appears accurate enough. By then, both men had been made to earn their pay.

What made the contest memorable was not any single dramatic incident, for there were no knockdowns and no controversies of consequence, but the quality of the resistance Brewer supplied and the degree to which Calzaghe had to answer it. Calzaghe’s earlier title defences had often been won with such speed and fluency that they left little room to judge his staying power. Here, he had to show it. He had to absorb solid shots, steady himself when Brewer came on in the second half, and keep punching with enough discipline to hold the fight together. Afterwards, he said he had needed to dig deep, and that was one point on which there was no reason to doubt him. Brewer had come to fight, not merely to survive, and he was still asking questions at the end.

In the end, the official verdict was broad but not unfair. A score of 119-109 was severe, though the other two cards, 118-111 and 117-112, gave a truer sense of the night: Calzaghe clearly the winner, Brewer clearly no passenger. For Calzaghe, it was another successful defence and another step in a reign that was growing longer and more accomplished with each passing year. For Brewer, it was a losing effort of some substance, the sort that confirmed his standing as a difficult and durable championship opponent even in defeat. The fight did not resolve all the larger questions around Calzaghe’s place in the division, but it did establish one thing plainly enough. When asked to go the long road by an experienced and determined challenger, he could still travel it and arrive first.

Brewer was a challenge that I believe Calzaghe took extremely seriously. I think it showed during the fight that he knew that the former IBF champion had a chip on his shoulder over how he had been treated in his two fights against German Sven Ottke, and that he came to Wales expecting the same treatment.

What is worth remembering is that Brewer had suffered another defeat after the second Ottke fight, a vacant NABA super-middleweight title loss to Antwun Echols, in which Echols was down three times in the second round, only to come back and stop Brewer in the third. Brewer scored a win against Fernando Zuniga(W-UD-12) to win the same vacant NABA super-middleweight title before challenging Calzaghe.

Brewer was one of those rare fighters who were often knocked down in fights but didn’t seem to suffer any ill effects going forward in his career. For instance, stoppage losses to Lonny Beasley, Rafael Williams, and Rodney Toney in 1994 were followed by a nine-fight unbeaten run, during which he won and retained his IBF crown on three occasions.

No matter how driven Brewer was when he faced Calzaghe, the Welshman always had the answer to his challenger. It was a hard fight, but Calzaghe mostly came away at the end of each round looking like the winner.

Brewer once again came back with three wins against good opposition, but then suffered back-to-back stoppage losses to Mario Veit and Lolenga Mock, persuading him to retire for good.