Jermell Charlo vs Brian Castano

Jermell Charlo and Brian Castaño failed by the narrowest margin to settle the world super-welterweight championship when they fought to a split draw over 12 rounds at the AT&T Centre in San Antonio, Texas, on 17 July 2021. Charlo entered as the WBC, WBA and IBF champion, while Castaño held the WBO title. A victory for either man would have produced the first undisputed super-welterweight champion of the four-belt era. Instead, each retained his championships after judges Steve Weisfeld, Nelson Vazquez and Tim Cheatham returned sharply differing scores.

Charlo, from Houston, weighed 153 pounds and brought a record of 34 victories, one defeat and one draw. Castaño, the undefeated Argentine, scaled 153¼ pounds and entered with 17 wins and one draw. Charlo had unified three titles by stopping Jeison Rosario the previous September and possessed advantages in height, reach and individual punching power. Castaño was the shorter and more active fighter, accustomed to forcing his way inside behind a high guard and sustaining pressure with both hands. Hector Afu was the referee.

Castaño advanced from the opening bell and immediately attempted to reduce Charlo’s space. He jabbed towards the body, worked his way inside and forced the taller champion towards the ropes. Charlo remained patient, moving around the perimeter and looking for counters rather than trying to match Castaño’s output. The Argentine did much of the early work, although Charlo showed in the second round how dangerous his measured approach could be. A counter left hook caught Castaño cleanly and sent him staggering backwards. Charlo followed, but Castaño recovered without going down and resumed his forward pressure.

The third and fourth rounds belonged largely to Castaño’s method. He stepped beneath Charlo’s longer punches, drove him back and attacked with compact hooks and straight rights. Charlo was frequently placed against the ropes, where he relied upon his guard, upper-body movement and occasional counter left hook. Castaño did not punch recklessly. He applied pressure in measured bursts, often finishing his combinations to the body before moving his head away from Charlo’s return. Charlo landed the occasional heavier blow, but Castaño was initiating more exchanges and completing more sustained work.

The contest settled into a demanding pattern through the fifth and sixth rounds. Charlo attempted to establish his jab and create sufficient room for the straight right, but Castaño continued passing beneath the lead hand and forcing close exchanges. The Argentine’s body punching was particularly useful. He struck beneath Charlo’s elbows, kept his feet beneath him and remained close enough to prevent the champion from using his full reach. Charlo sometimes found room for short hooks and uppercuts, but his offence came in isolated bursts. Castaño’s work was steadier and gave him the appearance of controlling the fight.

Castaño continued to press during the seventh and eighth. He was willing to absorb a counter in order to reach his preferred range, and his greater activity repeatedly placed Charlo on the defensive. Charlo remained composed and was never overwhelmed, but he spent long periods waiting for a perfect opening rather than producing enough punches to influence the judges. When he did let his hands go, the difference in force was evident. Castaño’s head was turned by several hooks and right hands, yet he answered quickly and refused to surrender the initiative.

The ninth followed much the same course. Castaño crowded Charlo, worked in combinations and made the champion retreat. Charlo’s defence prevented many punches from landing cleanly, but he was still being outworked. Castaño appeared to have established a useful advantage entering the final three rounds. His difficulty was that the pressure had required considerable energy, while Charlo remained capable of changing the fight with one accurate counter.

That moment came in the tenth. Charlo caught Castaño with a heavy left hook, which disturbed the challenger’s balance and drove him backwards. Castaño’s legs became unsteady, and Charlo followed with right hands and further hooks as the Argentine retreated towards the ropes. For much of the round, Castaño was in serious difficulty. He attempted to answer rather than merely hold, but his punches lacked their previous force. Charlo had his clearest opportunity to end the contest, though Castaño survived without touching the canvas.

Castaño recovered sufficiently to continue in the eleventh, but Charlo had finally taken control of the distance. The taller man used his jab more effectively, found the target with his right hand, and prevented Castaño from resuming the sustained pressure that had carried him through the middle rounds. Castaño remained willing and continued advancing, although his movements had slowed and Charlo’s counters were now arriving with greater regularity.

Charlo’s trainer, Derrick James, urged him to seek a knockout before the final round. Charlo responded by boxing with greater urgency, keeping Castaño outside and landing the cleaner blows. Castaño continued to press and finished the contest on his feet, but he could not reproduce the volume or authority of his earlier work. Charlo had swept the last three rounds on all three official scorecards, an achievement which proved sufficient to preserve the draw.

Weisfeld scored the contest 114–113 for Castaño. Cheatham returned an even card of 114–114. Vazquez awarded Charlo a widely criticised 117–111 verdict, giving the American nine of the 12 rounds. The final score produced a split draw. Castaño believed he had done enough to win, while Charlo argued that his heavier punching and strong finish had earned him the decision. The 117–111 card was difficult to reconcile with the competitive nature of the fight and the Argentine’s long periods of control.

The punch statistics supported Castaño’s claim to have done the greater volume of effective work. He landed 173 of 586 punches, compared with Charlo’s 151 from 533. More significantly, Castaño held an advantage of 164 to 98 in power punches. Charlo landed more jabs and produced the fight’s most damaging individual moments, particularly in the second and tenth rounds, but Castaño’s pressure and combination punching carried much of the contest.

A draw was not an impossible verdict because several rounds were close, and Charlo finished strongly. The score of 117–111 in his favour, however, obscured a performance in which Castaño had repeatedly forced the champion backwards, outworked him at close range and appeared to win most of the middle rounds. Neither man became undisputed champion that night, but the quality and uncertainty of the contest made a second meeting unavoidable. They met again ten months later, when Charlo settled the argument by knocking Castaño out in the tenth round.

I had Brian Castano winning this fight. Jermell Charlo carried the heavier single-shot power and held the WBC, WBA and IBF belts, while Castaño brought the WBO title and that relentless Argentine pressure. The prize was an undisputed championship at 154 pounds, and Castano boxed like the man who wanted it more.

Charlo hurt him with a left hook in the second and nearly finished him in the tenth, so this was no robbery in the sense of one man being completely outclassed. But across the full 12 rounds, Castano did the better work. He forced Charlo backwards, crowded his long punches and kept letting combinations go to the body and head. Charlo spent too much time waiting for the perfect counter while Castaño was banking rounds.

The punch figures backed that up. Castano landed 173 punches to Charlo’s 151 and held a huge advantage in power shots, 164 to 98. Charlo swept the final three rounds on all the official cards, but he needed that finish because he had allowed too much of the middle fight to slip away.

A draw was generous to Charlo. The 117–111 card in his favour was a disgrace and bore no relation to what happened in the ring. Even Charlo later admitted the margin was too wide.

For me, Castano won a close but clear fight through pressure, volume and proper inside work. Charlo produced the biggest moments; Castano produced the better overall performance.